PARIS, November 21 (Aalimi Nation) – A Paris criminal court has sentenced three police officers to five-year prison terms, most of them suspended, for beating Black music producer Michel Zecler at his studio in 2020, a verdict described as rare in a country where convictions in police violence cases are uncommon.
Sentences handed down
The court gave each of the three officers a five-year sentence on Friday, 20 November, after a trial over the 2020 assault. For Aurelien Lapersonne, 29, three years were suspended. For Philippe Tondeux, 50, three and a half years were suspended. Pierre Plantier, 37, received four suspended years and will serve the remaining year with an electronic ankle tag rather than in prison.
What happened in 2020
Officers stopped Zecler outside his Paris studio on 21 November 2020, during the Covid-19 restrictions. They accused him of not wearing a mandatory mask and suspected him of cannabis use. They then pushed him into the entrance of his office and beat him. The studio's security cameras recorded the assault.
A medical report recorded head and facial trauma, wounds to the lip and scalp, and a complete rupture of a biceps tendon. Zecler was unable to work for 45 days.
The officers' arrest report said Zecler had struck them and tried to seize a weapon. Footage published by a news website several days later contradicted that account. The case caused national outrage at the time and renewed debate in France over police use of force.
A rare conviction
Most allegations of police brutality in France are dealt with internally and seldom reach a criminal court, according to accounts of the case. Guilty verdicts are rarer still.
In 2024, three officers received suspended prison sentences for assaulting a young Black man, Theo Luhaka, during a stop-and-search in 2017.
Police unions and authorities have generally maintained that police violence is limited to isolated cases. Victims, campaigners and some researchers say the problem is systemic. Rights groups and campaigners see such cases as evidence of racism within the police.
Data on police stops
A report by France's rights chief last year found that young men perceived as Arab, Black or of North African origin are four times more likely to be stopped by police than the rest of the population. The report also found they are 12 times more likely to face more severe checks.
Campaigners cite such figures as evidence of discriminatory policing. The findings are those of the rights chief's report; they do not address the Zecler verdict itself.
What comes next
The accounts of the verdict reviewed did not say whether the officers or prosecutors intend to appeal, so it is not clear whether the sentences are final.
Attention in France is also turning to the upcoming trial of a police officer over the 2023 killing of Nahel Merzouk, which has kept police conduct on the national agenda.







