NEW DELHI, November 20 (Aalimi Nation) – The Supreme Court on Friday dismissed the Karnataka government's appeal seeking to restore a ban on bike taxis, leaving in place a High Court ruling that allows motorcycle taxi services in the state. A bench that included Justice Satish Chandra Sharma delivered the order.

The High Court had held in January 2026 that the state may impose regulatory conditions but cannot refuse permits simply because a vehicle is a motorcycle. It also held that motorcycles can be registered as transport vehicles under the Motor Vehicles Act. The Karnataka government challenged that ruling in the Supreme Court, as did five auto and taxi driver associations, which argued that unregulated bike taxis would hurt existing operators.

What the Court observed

During the hearings, the bench questioned the state's concern about traffic congestion, pointing out that motorcycles take up less road space than cars. It also highlighted how affordable bike taxis are for commuters.

Justice Sharma was reported to have said that "it is better to regulate it than ban it," and noted that bike taxis already operate in 25 states. Comparing costs, he observed that an auto-rickshaw is "five times the cost." He also remarked that a bike taxi "is safer for young girls as it has GPS as well." These remarks come from reports of the hearings; the written order was not available at the time of writing.

The state's case

Karnataka argued that the Motor Vehicles Act defines motorcycles and motor cabs separately, and that its aggregator rules did not contemplate bike taxis. It contended that aggregators have no inherent right to run such services. The state also pointed to a 2019 expert committee report that raised concerns about safety, congestion and pollution, and cited worries over passenger safety and insurance coverage.

The state said it was willing to consider allowing bike taxis in other parts of Karnataka but opposed operations in Bengaluru.

Aggregators and the Centre

Ride-hailing aggregators told the Court that about 4.5 lakh passengers in Karnataka use bike taxis. They relied on an earlier High Court ruling that had not been challenged, along with central government notifications issued in 2004 and 2024. In response to a query from the bench, the Centre confirmed that its notifications allow motorcycles to be used as taxis.

What the ruling means

The decision leaves in place the High Court's finding that a state cannot refuse permits merely because a vehicle is a motorcycle. It does not remove the state's power to regulate: the High Court held that the government may impose conditions.

Under the High Court's directions, operators can apply for permits. It is not yet clear what conditions Karnataka will frame for safety, insurance and aggregator operations, or whether it will continue to oppose bike taxis in Bengaluru. The written order was not available at the time of writing.