NEW DELHI, November 19 (Aalimi Nation) – Congress leader Rahul Gandhi's remarks on the Indian economy at a university in the United States have drawn a sharp response from the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), reviving a recurring political argument over what opposition leaders say about India while abroad.

Gandhi, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, spoke at a fireside chat at Columbia University in New York on Tuesday, answering questions from students, faculty and academics.

What Rahul Gandhi said

He said India was "sitting on an economic disaster", pointing to heavy unemployment, a weak manufacturing base and deep-rooted problems in the education system.

Gandhi argued that the economic model followed by the Modi government had stopped delivering results almost a decade ago. He questioned whether initiatives such as Make in India and Start-up India had rebuilt manufacturing or created enough jobs, and said services alone could not absorb a growing workforce.

BJP response to the economic disaster remark

BJP spokesperson Pradeep Bhandari said Gandhi had "become the leader of anti-India propaganda". He criticised Gandhi's conduct as Leader of the Opposition and said the remarks insulted the spirit of the national flag. He contrasted Gandhi with Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who he said upheld national interests when travelling abroad.

BJP national media convener Ashish Usha Agarwal described Gandhi's criticism of India on foreign soil as a recurring pattern and asked what its objective was. In a post on X, he cited growth projections of 7 per cent for 2026-27 from the International Monetary Fund and Moody's, 7.1 per cent from professional forecasters surveyed by the Reserve Bank of India, and 6.9 per cent for 2026 from Goldman Sachs.

Agarwal also cited a World Bank report, saying poverty measured at the lower-middle-income benchmark had fallen from 57.7 per cent to 16.1 per cent, lifting about 496 million people out of poverty. These figures are the BJP leader's own citations and were not independently checked here.

Political context

The exchange follows a pattern seen on earlier foreign visits by Gandhi, when the BJP accused him of defaming India abroad and the Congress replied that it was raising legitimate questions about governance. No fresh response from the Congress to the latest BJP criticism was available at the time of writing.

At home, the Congress has pressed the Centre on prices this week. Party leader Jairam Ramesh cited October retail inflation of 6.09 per cent and food inflation of 8.94 per cent, and asked the government to publish a white paper on inflation, while disputing the Centre's claims on poverty reduction.

The economy has been a consistent line of attack for the opposition, which points to jobs and prices, while the government cites headline growth and poverty data. Both sides draw on different indicators, and economists often read the same figures differently depending on the measure used.

What next

The debate is likely to continue in public statements and on social media. Any official response from the government to the growth and jobs claims, and any further comment from the Congress, will be reported as they are confirmed.